
Some leaders are just quiet. They’re not volatile, and they’re not harsh. They subscribe to the no-news-is-good-news theory: if I’m not hearing that anything is wrong, everything must be right. Or perhaps no news means nothing has changed, and “I’ll update you once something has.” Like the old joke about the married couple where the wife points out that her husband hasn’t said “I love you” in 50 years. “True,” he replies, adding, “I said I love you on our wedding day; if anything changes, I’ll let you know.”
That’s not the absence of conflict. That’s conflict avoidance dressed up as calm.
Some leaders, if they had the courage to say it out loud, might admit: I’m conflict avoidant. I’m having issues with my team, and I’m afraid to address them. So instead I make excuses. I tell myself it’ll work out. Or I assume someone else, someone less conflict-avoidant who has stepped up for me in the past, will take care of it. Or I beat around the bush so thoroughly that nobody is quite sure what I meant.
What I find interesting is who does this. I work with Law Enforcement, for example, whose jobs are conflict. They pull people over, walk into domestic violence calls, respond to a robbery in progress. You’d think they’d be the least afraid of it. But it’s not uncommon for people in these kinds of professions to be comfortable with conflict on the job and much less comfortable with it in the business of the work — or in their personal life. Back in the office, facing a peer or a direct report, they can be far more conflict-averse. Comfort with conflict is situational, just like confidence.
For the team, the cost looks different than it does with a volatile leader. In this case, nobody’s bracing for an outburst. Instead, the behavior, issue, or problem that should have been addressed persists because the person who needs to do something about it never does, and everyone else watches and wonders. The leader thinks they’re being kind, gentle, and patient. What the team experiences is someone unreliable and wishy-washy, someone they can’t count on to act, and respect erodes. The leader who keeps everyone guessing has a volatility problem. This leader, on the other hand, has a silence problem.
Quiet isn’t the same as kind. Often it’s just the slower road to the same conflict, with higher stakes.
If you’re not sure which kind of leader you are, ask the people who work for you: when you hear nothing from me, what do you assume? Then be brave enough to listen to the answer.
If you recognize yourself here and want a thought partner for the reset, I’m here.
Photo by Ernie A. Stephens on Unsplash
