
Here’s a quick test: If someone on your team described how you handled the last hard decision, how would they describe the decision, and how would they describe you?
Those are two different stories, and the best leaders make sure they stay that way.
A leader can make a decision that half the room hates and still be someone people respect by being clear about the decision, articulating the “whys” behind it, and being open about what happens next. In other words, they speak to the thoughts in everyone’s head. I’ve seen it. I’ve also seen the opposite: a leader who makes perfectly reasonable decisions but leaves their team on edge because the leader is uncomfortable with the decision and takes it out on the team, spreading anxiety and making sure everyone knows how unhappy they are, yet never providing the information and insights the team needs to process the decision in a healthy way.
Decoupling is the practice of pulling those things apart. The decision is one thing. How you treat people while you make it and deliver it is another. While that may seem like a “duh” sort of concept, the truth is that many leaders deliver bad news in an overly grumpy way and fail to bring their team into the understanding behind the decision or what happens next, leaving everyone to worry and guess — and we all know how well that combination works.
Take the hardest example: a layoff. Nobody’s going to love that decision, and nobody should be expected to. The leader’s job is to make the call. But whether people were treated with respect, whether the explanation was honest, whether anyone feels safe asking a question afterward, none of that is dictated by the decision. It’s a choice about how you treat people.
A leader can make a call people won’t like and still build a culture of psychological safety, where it’s okay to speak up, ask a question, or even disagree without fear of harm, repercussions, or retaliation. After all, you already know a decision will be unpopular. Why expect people to behave otherwise? A great leader gives people space to feel without taking those feelings personally.
This is where levels of responsibility matter. We don’t hold leaders to the same standard as the people they lead, because the weight of their decisions is different. But respect, honesty, and predictability aren’t part of that weight. They aren’t perks of the job that get traded away for hard calls. Different responsibilities don’t mean different rules about how we treat people. Gaslighting is wrong no matter who does it.
So the next time you have a hard call to make, remember that the decision is only part of what your team will carry with them. The rest is how you showed up, and that part is always your choice.
If you’re navigating a hard call and want help separating the decision from the delivery, let’s talk.
